Following Rlown's excellent instructions, here's an excel spreadsheet that contains a rank of order of major Sierra passes & peaks. Since it contains many of the eastside passes one would traverse on the way to Kaweah basin, I'll post it in this thread.
Note: this particular file is sorted by gain per mile. If one were so inclined, it can re-ordered along other criteria, such as maximum elevation, total gain, distance, etc. Also, for peaks & passes not starting from a fixed trailhead, my starting points are somewhat arbitrary, but reflect what I believe are logical overnight spots in which to stay before embarking early next morning.
https://docs.google.com/spreadsheet/pub ... utput=html" onclick="window.open(this.href);return false;
Dave, I've heard the same conflicting information and claims regarding Shepherd. In my mind, there are two distinct dangers resulting from the differing error types:
1. Underestimate the mileage and find out you have further to go
2. Overestimate the mileage and find out you've overestimated your ability
It's purely subjective and one of merely personally preference, but I naturally prefer to avoid #2. If I were to update my spreadsheet to indicate Shepherd was 12 miles rather than 9.5 - but it was actually in error (approx 25%), what happens if that error translated to a hike where I believed I was traveling 20 miles per day, but was actually only hiking 15? Then, based on this (over) confidence, I commit to a hike that really is 20 miles per day? This, of course, is the type of error one hears about occurring in run training.
Likewise, if I were to change the mileage to 12 from 9.5, it will effect the gain per mile. That is, make it seem less steep. Again, I'd rather err on my preferred side, rather than the other.
Lastly, I am aware of the distance discrepancies, and keep that in mind as a lot of this stuff is purely subjective based on weather condition, personal condition, how you are physically feeling that day, that hour, etc. For example, sometimes I can almost jog uphill @ 12k (like motoring up NAP), other times I can't figure out what's wrong me as a I keep stopping to catch my breath (cough, Forester, cough). LOL
As always, YMMV