R03/R01 TR: N. Lake to S. Lake via Piute Pass, Alpine Col, Muir Pass, Palisade Basin, Bishop Pass (8/6/24-8/10/24)

Post write ups, photos, stories, and reports from your trips into the High Sierra
User avatar
terrapin
Topix Novice
Posts: 15
Joined: Tue Jun 20, 2017 7:43 pm
Experience: Level 4 Explorer

R03/R01 TR: N. Lake to S. Lake via Piute Pass, Alpine Col, Muir Pass, Palisade Basin, Bishop Pass (8/6/24-8/10/24)

Post by terrapin »

My son and I only had an opportunity for a short trip this summer, and we decided to travel over some of Roper's SHR passes that were new to us. Our trip would be 4 nights and take us over Piute Pass, Alpine Col, Muir Pass, Cirque Pass, Potluck Pass, Knapsack Pass, and Bishop Pass. I had to be on the ball to get a Piute Pass permit at exactly 7am 14 days prior, but I was successful. They were gone in under a minute. The 14-day "walk-up" system that was implemented during Covid used to be a sure-fire way to get any Inyo permit, but the secret is out, unfortunately.

Day zero was stressful as we needed to: make the long drive to Bishop from the Bay Area and 1) get a walk-in campsite at North Lake, 2) drive to South Lake and find a parking spot to leave our car, and 3) hitchhike back to our campsite at North Lake. It all worked, fortunately, as I didn't have a plan B. The North Lake campground initially appeared full, but it turns out the parking spots were taken up by day hikers. Maddening to say the least, but it was a relief when we realized that campsites were available. By the time I drove to South Lake (I left my son at the campground), it was late Monday afternoon, South Lake was quiet, and parking was easy. Unfortunately that meant that hitchhiking opportunities were scarce. I was clean (relatively), carrying nothing, and just wanted a ride down the hill to the highway junction (planning on another hitch up to the North Lake Rd.). But something about me was off putting and the 2-3 drivers who left the parking lot in the first 20 minutes didn't stop. But finally a nice couple did. They dropped me off at the highway, where I then tried to thumb a ride up to the North Lake Rd. junction, from where I was planning to walk. Again a few passed up the opportunity to give me a ride but then a very nice gal my age (60ish) who had a house in Aspendell stopped and insisted on driving me all the way to the North Lake campground. My faith in humanity restored, my son and I ate a hearty dinner that we had procured from a taco truck in Bishop.

Day 1: North Lake to Darwin Bench via Piute Pass and Alpine Col

We had 3 options for this day: 1) Piute Pass/Alpine Col, 2) Piute Pass/Snow Tongue Pass, and 3) Lamarck Col. We chose #1; #3 was too short (and a different permit, but that's a separate issue), and regarding #2, I wasn't keen on going up Snow Tongue Pass or dealing with the traverse above Evolution Valley. The Alpine Col route seemed like it would be nothing but beautiful country, albeit with lots of talus to enjoy.

We made good time to Piute Pass (looking towards Summit Lake and Humphries Basin):

Image

From there it wasn't far to Muriel Lake and then to the outlet of Goethe Lake. I hadn't looked at the map closely and didn't realize that Muriel Lake was about the same elevation as Piute Pass, which was kind of nice. Muriel Lake:

Image

From Goethe Lake the use trail ends and the talus fun begins. We were expecting it, and hopping the talus along the west shore of Goethe Lake didn't seem bad at all:

Image

Climbing up to Alpine Col was slow, but we made steady progress. We basically aimed left, then switched back to the right to reach the top.

Alpine Col from the west shore of Goethe Lake:

Image

On the lower slopes we decided to try going up the middle on what looked like a use trail through loose scree, thinking it might be faster than the talus. But it was too steep and loose, so we headed left to the stable (and enormous) talus:

Image

The top is in sight:

Image

Last few steps, Goethe Lake in the background:

Image

View down the SE side of Alpine Col and Lake 11910:

Image

It was only about 2pm at the summit of Alpine Col and we just had a few miles left to make it to Darwin Bench. It looked like we'd be in camp early. It ended up taking us over 3 hours! The talus was seemingly endless. I was mentally prepared for hopping talus to get up Alpine Col and then to descend to the first lake (11910), but not for it to continue for so long afterwards. We traversed the east short of Lake 11910:

Image

We then dropped down to the isthmus between Lakes 11546 and 11540:

Image

From there we had to choose which side of Lake 11540 to travel. The NW shore was longer and the terrain was steeper, so I had planned on the SW shore. But there was a steep snowfield along the way that went up several hundred feet from the lake. From our vantage point it looked like there were footsteps across it near lake level, and we gambled that we'd be comfortable crossing it (we weren't carrying any traction). But when we got there, it was far too steep and slick for comfort. A fall would drop us into the lake or worse. So we had to climb about 300' and do some painstaking maneuvering around some more giant talus to get around it:

Image

I had clearly picked the wrong side of the lake. But once we were passed the snowfield, it was smooth sailing, more or less, to the Darwin Bench area which was absolutely gorgeous:

Image


Day 2: Darwin Bench to Le Conte Canyon via Muir Pass

Today was mostly on trail, not necessarily unwelcome after all the talus yesterday. Getting down to the JMT from Darwin Bench was a little slower than expected, but was easy enough. It was certainly beautiful:

Image

Then it was the familiar (for us) JMT over Muir Pass and down to Le Conte Canyon. It's always a bit jarring to see so many people after experiencing the solitude of being off trail, but it is truly a beautiful section of trail:

Image

Muir Pass was busy, and quite warm for 12,000 ft. There was no snow anywhere worth mentioning. Our pace was such that we were going to end up camping somewhere in Le Conte Canyon. I knew it would be challenging to find a secluded camp spot but we were successful, finding one between the trail and the river about a mile past the Bishop Pass trail. The skies were threatening in the late afternoon and there was ominous thunder but we only got some light sprinkles.

Day 3: Le Conte Canyon to "Cirque Basin" via Cirque Pass

During the JMT portion of the day we hiked quickly, down to Piute Creek and then up through Deer Meadow and up the Golden Staircase and its beautiful views:

Image

We left the JMT to head up Cirque Pass before reaching Lower Palisade Lake, and soon stopped to have lunch at the first little tarn on the way up. Lower slopes of Cirque Pass:

Image

Climbing Cirque Pass was enjoyable, with only one section of talus on the second half of the climb:

Image

We generally did well with our route finding, but I had studied the route (and routes of the other passes) prior to the trip. The weather was a bit concerning; generally OK in the direction we were headed but ominous behind us. We could see that Mather Pass was getting hammered with a thunderstorm, but we were dry for the time being (Palisade Lakes and Mather Pass):

Image

We were planning on stopping at the lake that feeds Glacier Creek (11676, some call this Cirque Basin) and we had plenty of time to get there. Cross-country travel is so much more enjoyable when you have no time pressure. The views at the top of the pass were wonderful; it was nice to see across to the Marion Peak area that we had traveled through a couple of years ago when we did the beginning section of the SHR.

Looking south from Cirque Pass, identification of the peaks is left as an exercise for the reader (i.e. I have no idea):

Image

Looking north from Cirque Pass:

Image

From the top it was a straightforward descent to the outlet of Lake 11676, where we set up our tent in a stunning area beneath the Palisade Crest:

Image

View across Paliside Creek from campsite:

Image

Day 4: Cirque Basin to Timberline Tarns via Potluck Pass, Knapsack Pass, and Bishop Pass

Potluck Pass would have been difficult for us had I not done my research beforehand. I realize some would say I was cheating, but I'm not a fan of unplanned exposure, particularly when hiking with my son. So, it was relatively straightforward, hiking up the loose scree to the left of the pass:

Image

Adding in some safe scrambling:

Image

Until we reached the easy ramps to the top:

Image

View SE from Potluck Pass:

Image

From Potluck Pass it was relatively easy hiking to and over Roper's "Inconspicuous Saddle":

Image

We had an early lunch at the upper Barrett Lake and then headed towards Knapsack Pass. Looking down Palisade Basin:

Image

For some reason I had thought that the Knapsack Pass climb would be trivial but it involved traversing some steep talus. We might have erred by trying to maintain our elevation by staying right, as it looked like it might have been smoother to drop down and head up the middle. Regardless, the views were spectacular and we made it up.

Nearing the pass:

Image

Looking SE from Knapsack Pass:

Image

Looking NW from Knapsack Pass into Dusy Basin:

Image

We didn't bother trying to maintain our elevation as we headed next to Bishop Pass, thinking it would be faster just to make a beeline to the Bishop Pass trail. We still botched it somewhat as instead of heading directly to the chain of lakes in the previous photo we veered right, as instinct kept us higher up. We ended up doing some needless bushwhacking. But we made it to the trail soon enough, where it was then clear sailing to Bishop Pass. Dusy Basin is always a treat to walk through. It rained lightly over the pass, but there was no threat of lightning.

Starting the descent east from Bishop Pass:

Image

We could have easily made it out to the car well before dark, but I wasn't going to drive all the way back to the Bay Area, and staying in a motel somewhere is much less appealing to me then camping, so we hunted for a spot. Unfortunately, it was now Friday afternoon and there were tents and hikers everywhere. We eventually made our way down to the Timberline Tarns below Saddlerock Lake and scouted for a private site and succeeded.

Day 5: Timberline Tarns to South Lake

It was only 3.5 miles downhill to our car so the day was very brief. We did encounter a gentlemen who was heading up and stopped us and asked if we had any spare sunglasses. I wear prescription lenses but my son was sporting a pair of not-terribly-expensive sunglasses. Since we were about done and he was just starting out, I offered them to him. He was very appreciative and of course offered to pay, but his gratitude was payment enough.

Smug with fresh, good karma I wished him luck and then not 5 minutes later proceeded to snap one of my carbon hiking poles when I jammed it between two rocks. These are the Gossamer Gear poles that are notoriously fragile, in my experience and that of many others. I got them on sale and love them for day hikes but have never used them on a backpacking trip. Just that morning I had commented on how lucky I was that they had survived (maybe the jinx from that remark outweighed the sunglasses karma). Anyway, GG sells individual pole sections so repair isn't too expensive.

The South Lake parking lot was a very different scene from when I had dropped off the car, completely full, with cars circling like buzzards. When we told a driver who was hovering that we were leaving and our spot was his, he was more excited than the sunglasses guy.
Last edited by terrapin on Tue Nov 26, 2024 10:36 pm, edited 1 time in total.
User avatar
freestone
Topix Expert
Posts: 984
Joined: Fri Nov 11, 2005 9:42 pm
Experience: Level 3 Backpacker
Location: Santa Barbara
Contact:

Re: TR: N. Lake to S. Lake via Alpine Col, Muir Pass, Palisade Basin, Bishop Pass (8/6/24-8/10/24)

Post by freestone »

Awesome report and pictures. Thank you for sharing your story.
Short cuts make long delays. JRR Tolkien
User avatar
Wandering Daisy
Topix Docent
Posts: 7051
Joined: Sun Jan 24, 2010 8:19 pm
Experience: N/A
Location: Fair Oaks CA (Sacramento area)
Contact:

Re: TR: N. Lake to S. Lake via Alpine Col, Muir Pass, Palisade Basin, Bishop Pass (8/6/24-8/10/24)

Post by Wandering Daisy »

Thanks for the trip report. I missed you by one day; I came out from Piute Lake to North Lake on Aug 5. I would have picked you up if I saw you were trying to get to North Lake. I always pick up backpackers. I have hitched a lot myself.

A few days earlier (Aug 2-3) it was quite a zoo up by Muriel Lake. One fellow coming down from Alpine Col had lost his partner, overnight, and was looking for him. I also learned from another person who went up Alpine Col that she met a different hiker who was left behind by his group who had gone up Alpine Col. She tried to help him contact his family. He was so distraught that he could not figure out how to use is PLB. There were helicopters flying around for two days after.

Researching passes is NOT cheating! It is being prepared.

I really like Barrett Lakes. I have spent quite a bit of time there climbing all the peaks.

You are lucky that your son backpacks with you. My kids and grandkids are way too busy to backpack with me, although one daughter backpacked with me when she was in High School. They grow up and go on their own way too soon.
User avatar
terrapin
Topix Novice
Posts: 15
Joined: Tue Jun 20, 2017 7:43 pm
Experience: Level 4 Explorer

Re: TR: N. Lake to S. Lake via Alpine Col, Muir Pass, Palisade Basin, Bishop Pass (8/6/24-8/10/24)

Post by terrapin »

Freestone: thank you.

Daisy: yes, I am lucky my son backpacks with me! Despite his father's age he's still in high school, but he's a senior so I'm afraid his days of being my partner are numbered. It was fun while it lasted and I have many wonderful memories. We've also done a fair amount of bike touring too.

Wow, I'm glad I missed all the drama between Muriel Lake and Alpine Col!

I was being a bit facetious about researching passes being cheating, but there's research, and there's research. I really researched.
User avatar
balzaccom
Topix Addict
Posts: 3111
Joined: Wed Dec 17, 2008 9:22 pm
Experience: N/A

Re: TR: N. Lake to S. Lake via Alpine Col, Muir Pass, Palisade Basin, Bishop Pass (8/6/24-8/10/24)

Post by balzaccom »

Great report and photos.

I wish it were summer again. I'm ready to go backpacking...
Check our our website: http://www.backpackthesierra.com/
Or just read a good mystery novel set in the Sierra; https://www.amazon.com/Danger-Falling-R ... 0984884963
User avatar
druid
Topix Regular
Posts: 165
Joined: Mon Aug 08, 2011 12:50 pm
Experience: N/A

Re: TR: N. Lake to S. Lake via Alpine Col, Muir Pass, Palisade Basin, Bishop Pass (8/6/24-8/10/24)

Post by druid »

Thanks for the great report and photos. I had a similar experience hitchhiking from South Lake to North Lake, also with my son. We were able to sweet talk our way into a ride down from South Lake fairly quickly, but then had a long wait at the Sabrina Lake intersection as we watched cars fly by up the hill. Our backup plan was to take the shuttle (which was still running back then) and then walk the North Lake road. We watched the shuttle pass by on the way up to South Lake and then later just as we saw it coming back down and were beginning to cross over the highway to catch it two backpackers stopped and gave us a ride all the way to North Lake.

I've never been over Alpine Col and your photos of the route are particularly helpful. I share the same concerns as you when I'm hiking with my son and daughter and as a consequence also do very "thorough" planning when I'm going to go hiking with them. Don't give up hope - both of mine are already out of college and I can still occasionally talk them into joining me for a trip.
User avatar
wildhiker
Topix Fanatic
Posts: 1212
Joined: Tue Jul 26, 2011 4:44 pm
Experience: Level 4 Explorer
Location: Palo Alto, CA
Contact:

Re: TR: N. Lake to S. Lake via Piute Pass, Alpine Col, Muir Pass, Palisade Basin, Bishop Pass (8/6/24-8/10/24)

Post by wildhiker »

Very nice report and photos. So many grand views from the passes! As I'm following along on your route, I'm thinking: man, these guys are fast! Or maybe I'm just slow. Your route would probably take me twice as long. I've only done the first two passes on your trip (Piute Pass and Alpine Col). It sounds like you had no real problems on Alpine Col. My wife and I did it in the opposite direction, south to north, and found that descending through the giant talus on the north side was really nerve-wracking. I have no desire to ever do that pass again.

Glad to hear that your "son on the verge of adulthood" is still backpacking with you. We did family backpacks all the way through the high school years with our kids. Then they had to establish themselves separately and didn't want to hang out with us, but in their late 20s and 30s starting doing occasional backpack trips with us again when they were in town. My second daughter even invited us to trek (backpack) with her in Patagonia ten years ago. When I asked why she wasn't going with her friends, she replied that none of her friends were tough enough to do that trip, but she knew we could handle it (we were in our 60s)! It was a great trip, made better by the fact that this daughter was fluent in Spanish. And just this past summer, we took our older daughter and her two girls (8 and 5) on the girls' first very short backpack trip with us in the Sierra (my son-in-law couldn't make it due to work commitments). So here's some evidence that if your son enjoyed his trips with you, he probably will still want to backpack with Dad as an adult.

-Phil
User avatar
LMBSGV
Topix Fanatic
Posts: 1058
Joined: Sat Oct 27, 2007 8:42 pm
Experience: Level 4 Explorer
Location: San Geronimo, CA
Contact:

Re: TR: N. Lake to S. Lake via Piute Pass, Alpine Col, Muir Pass, Palisade Basin, Bishop Pass (8/6/24-8/10/24)

Post by LMBSGV »

Thank you for sharing your amazing journey from North Lake to South Lake. It was great to read and see an account that did not follow the traditional trailed route. You sure put in the miles every day. I am envious of your speed on such difficult terrain. Your trip helped me remember being able to cover a lot ground every day and helped me recall so many great memories like going from Palisade Basin over Knapsack Pass to South Lake on my last day in 2004.

I also appreciated how your son is such an intrepid fellow traveler. Mine continued to backpacking with my wife and I until he was in college when he gave it up. Here's hoping your son will continue to join you after high school.
I don’t need a goal destination. I need a destination that meets my goals.

http://laurencebrauer.com
User avatar
Bishop_Bob
Topix Regular
Posts: 212
Joined: Wed Jun 05, 2019 11:31 am
Experience: Level 3 Backpacker

Re: TR: N. Lake to S. Lake via Piute Pass, Alpine Col, Muir Pass, Palisade Basin, Bishop Pass (8/6/24-8/10/24)

Post by Bishop_Bob »

Indeed, it's not best to pass Lake 11540 above its eastern shore. The west side is an easy traverse, though it doesn't look like it would be from afar.
User avatar
Harlen
Topix Addict
Posts: 2390
Joined: Sat Mar 11, 2017 9:13 am
Experience: Level 4 Explorer
Location: Santa Cruz Mountains

Re: TR: N. Lake to S. Lake via Piute Pass, Alpine Col, Muir Pass, Palisade Basin, Bishop Pass (8/6/24-8/10/24)

Post by Harlen »

Terrapin, what a great trip and trip report! You do such an excellent job of leading us along with you. The photos are great for their documentary purpose, but many are just plain fantastic images. We enjoy seeing you guys in the photos--it brings the story to life. Our favorites are "Looking north from Cirque Pass," and especially the one of your son's back as he seems to be enjoying the beauty of lower Evolution Valley. It is below the heading "Day 2: Darwin Bench to LeConte Canyon..."

We really think that is a special image, and hope you'll blow it up and hang it in a prominent place. (Note, our house is happily full of such photos.)
Lastly, take hope in the stories of giantbrookie's backpacking children, and wildhiker's story. Lizzie and I hope that we too are on the cusp on that sort of change, as both son's have recently asked to join us on some trips. It's the best!

20240926_150311.jpg
Properly trained, a man can be dog’s best friend.
Post Reply

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 3 guests