Re: Granny does Roper's High Route IV
Posted: Thu Oct 04, 2018 12:43 pm
It isn't about rock climbing. It's about him becoming mellow or flowery. Forty is young in terms of the steady decrease in testosterone that turns some men into androgynous softies in their later years.
I'm happy Roper wrote his books. But at the same time I've never liked his writing style. I had to struggle to read Camp 4. It's not a question of whether it matters or not, it's just my opinion.
When I first thought of walking the whole SHR in one go I considered distilling his book, extracting just the pertinent details on the route-finding, and leaving all the other stuff behind. But he weaves the route descriptions and history/flora/geology together too tightly. It's bonded to the narrative. So I gave up on the project. But if it were available I'll bet it would be popular.
Some guidebooks take the approach of including the history, etc. in the introduction or appendices. Or as sidebars to the text. I'd have preferred he did that.
I'm happy Roper wrote his books. But at the same time I've never liked his writing style. I had to struggle to read Camp 4. It's not a question of whether it matters or not, it's just my opinion.
When I first thought of walking the whole SHR in one go I considered distilling his book, extracting just the pertinent details on the route-finding, and leaving all the other stuff behind. But he weaves the route descriptions and history/flora/geology together too tightly. It's bonded to the narrative. So I gave up on the project. But if it were available I'll bet it would be popular.
Some guidebooks take the approach of including the history, etc. in the introduction or appendices. Or as sidebars to the text. I'd have preferred he did that.