High Sierra Topix

My 1953 copy of Starr's Guide (1934) notes the trail descending directly south from Moraine Lake/Sky Parlor Meadow to the Big Arroyo Trail. This trail is shown on Starr's map, as well as some of Clyde's published maps.

Starr also notes "feasible routes for knapsackers down Whitney Creek" from Crabtree Meadow. Richins mentions such a route in his Mt Whitney guide, but the depiction in his publication's map is totally off. Thanks to Steve C of the Whitney Zone for his superb documentation of one of the Whitney Creek shortcut options.

No matter how one descends Whitney Creek, one is rewarded with a nice campsite next to the creek when the HST is met.

Jim

PS: I heard rumor that with the melting of the heavy snow in 2011, there was some earth movement along the Whitney Creek drainage that might have changed the game on the lower route. I talked to some trail crew (from Canada) in the Trench in July 2011. They said getting down to the Kern via the shortcut was not so easy as was anticipated. If anyone knows about this, your feedback would be appreciated.

This old map shows a trail SE from Moraine Lake going down directly to Big Arroyo:
http://caltopo.com/map.html#ll=36.44841 ... =14&b=1930

I’ve done the Chagoopa - Big Arroyo route 6 times (four descending, twice ascending which is harder) and the Cal Topo squares correctly. From Mineral King it’s the most direct access to the Kern and is mentioned in Steve Roper's "Climber's Guide to the High Sierra."

A person I know who “went west” from Moraine Lake said they ran into difficulties. A navigational aid descending is to aim for the Willow Creek-Big Arroyo confluence from the rim due south of the midpoint between the Sky Parlor junction and Moraine Lake.

Topo shows your route might cliff out between 9000 and 9080 feet. Tomba caltopo route is the obvious choice on the newer 7.5m USGS map. A great example of an area where those who don't make use of topos are apt to find themselves looking down a cliff after climbing down so far that climbing back up to escape would be painful. Head southeast from Moraine Lake directly towards the top of the big S in Sequoia (crosshairs on this mapper.acme topo)

http://mapper.acme.com/?ll=36.44922,-118.45038&z=15&t=T

then slide southwest to avoid another steep band 200 feet lower. Be sure to take a look at the satellite tab also and zoom in max.

fourputt wrote:I’ve done the Chagoopa - Big Arroyo route 6 times (four descending, twice ascending which is harder) and the Cal Topo squares correctly. From Mineral King it’s the most direct access to the Kern and is mentioned in Steve Roper's "Climber's Guide to the High Sierra."

A person I know who “went west” from Moraine Lake said they ran into difficulties. A navigational aid descending is to aim for the Willow Creek-Big Arroyo confluence from the rim due south of the midpoint between the Sky Parlor junction and Moraine Lake.

I led a Sierra Club group up the wall in 2011, and we essentially went up the slope opposite Willow Creek's main line. That was based on verbal advice from Gordon Peterson, long-time backpacker, who gave me his best recollection from his attempts to locate the old trail. We found the going tough, but never exposed or dangerous, just loose and brushy at times. Mostly a three-steps-up, two-back sort of ascent. We were up on top in about two hours, this was a group of eight people, two of them a bit slow. It would have been a fairly quick and safe descent.

And I'm going back there this coming summer, to see if I can improve on the route (and also get into Kaweah Basin). My general feeling is that the further one is willing to go to the east along Big Arroyo before ascending, the easier the going will be. Within reason, of course.