High Sierra Topix

http://www.wildsnow.com/2491/cilogear-n ... -backpack/" onclick="window.open(this.href);return false;

The hip belt is only 6 oz, and the strap set is 8 oz.
I may be just a skeptic, but how long is a 100 lb backpack with such a light
hip belt, and straps, really going to be comfortable?

I was thinking I needed a new pack this season. Lightweight, being the key. I wasnt looking to break the bank, $200 or so.

I went into REI and tried on some packs. I tried the Flash 65 and a couple others. What I determined was, the lightweight, cheaper stuff seems, well, flimsy.

Well, I broke out my trusty ol' Camp Trails Adirondack (internal frame). It's not pretty. It's not a trendy name brand, but its got beefy zippers, big cushy shoulders and belt, plenty of room, etc.......It's built like a tank. I"ve decided to cut weight in other areas and keep the beefy pack for now. If, and when I get another, it will be of construction that will last for many seasons. I'm not willing to sacrifice durability to save a pound or two on a pack. AND, I dont wanna spend a lot of money on a pack.

Hey Clubb,

I am looking at a Granite Gear Escape AC60. Hearing good things about the pack and it seems like a well thought out lightweight deal that runs about 200 bucks and 3 lbs. If the Regular size fits me well, it will be my lightweight setup pack. Unless something else comes up.....

I bought the Golight Quest (2 pounds 13 oz) last year and really like it. I think it is similar. It is a woman-specific pack, the first I have had. It has the same high quality suspension as the larger capacity pack (sorry cannot remember the name.) As for old external frame packs, I bought a Kelty pack (Tioga I think) from REI at the "garage sale" for $20 and ditched the packbag, hipbelt and shoulder straps and replaced them with lighter ones. Then I sewed my own packbag out of old stuff sacks. I made a strap system on the suspension bar that specifically fits my bear can. This is really a prototype and I will sew a bag out of better material when I get all the bugs worked out. Total weight = 3.5 pounds. And it is a real load carrier. I happen to like external frames.

Here is a photo of my home-made pack.

WD, do you have a picture of the frame side?

Here is a photo of the back with my old prototype bag. The first prototype I made a bag from an old REI raincover - it was too small so I later made a bigger bag from stuff sacks. I had thinner old straps and took the load lifters off the heavy Kelty straps and sewed them on. The new frames now are designed to attach with the load lifters. The mesh backpad is from another old pack. The hipbelt is an older one. I think it is a Jansport. Anyway, the point is that the frame itself is not that heavy - it is all the other junk that adds up weight. With a few adjustments, you can mix and match with other brand's shoulder straps and hip belts. It is getting harder to buy parts for external frame packs.

I used the pack shown on the last post on an 11-day trip and then a 5-day trip in the Wind River Mountains. It did quite well. The green nylon bands that I thought I would use to attach the Crocks did not work as planned.


The back of Prototype 1 - old 1968 Kelty framed.


Putting the extender bar on backwards made an indentation for the bear cannister so that it could be closer to my back. The cords and strap hanging down are for the bear can. I am short enough that the bear can does not hit my head - I think a taller person's head would hit the can.

I also have an old 1968 Kelty Frame that I use with a Granite Gear Virga (1 pound). I simply put the Virg on the pack as if the pack were a person. Then in camp I take the Virga off and use it as a day-pack. This was my pack that I used for climbing. I needed the external frame to carry all the climbing gear and rope and it was handy to not have to take in an extra day pack.

Another very old fashioned way to use an external frame is to simply lash on three zip bags using sleeping bag straps. One bag is sleeping pad and bag, one clothes and tent, the other food and cook gear.

So, this thread was started back in 2009 Markskor, what pack did you end up
getting, how is it working out for you?

WD wrote:

Another very old fashioned way to use an external frame is to simply lash on three zip bags using sleeping bag straps. One bag is sleeping pad and bag, one clothes and tent, the other food and cook gear

http://www.luxurylite.com/radlitepackindex.html" onclick="window.open(this.href);return false;

I see this as a similar concept, but somehow your Kelty solution seems more appropriate.