Passes and Classes
Posted: Tue Sep 05, 2006 6:37 pm
Here is an excellent link to a chart with most of the passes of the Sierra:
http://sierrabackpacker.com/sierrapasses-new.htm
I just came back from a trip where my pard and I put together a back-pack mountaineer cross-country (mostly) traverse of the Minarets, going from Fern Lake to 1,000 Island Lake. Once again I was struck by how lame the class ratings are for Class 1 through 3, especially for us who are not normally interested in anything above Class 3. The above link has an excellent explanation of 1-2-3, but I think the rating could go further.
For example, I would do a rating by class, difficulty and exposure. This is needed because, for example, a pass may be easy but very exposed, or very strenuous and somewhat technical but not exposed, and so on. The ratings would be in context of the Class. This is how I would rate things:
1) The Classes would match the explanation in the above link.
2) The Class could be followed by A through D in difficulty, with A being the most difficult/strenuous/technical.
3) The last could be the degree of exposure, 1 through 5, with 5 being the most exposed. A very important consideration.
For example:
A) I just did Nancy Pass, which I would rate as Class 2B1. The pass was not so dangerous (just the usual with loose talus and scree), but it was a pretty strenuous if short in length.
B) Mt. Conness I would rate Class 2D5. Pretty easy to do, but one move puts you over an exposure of about 2000 feet. Don’t slip.
C) Sphinx Pass, Class 2B1. Easy, but you will be very tired when you get there. No exposure.
D) Red Pass, Class 2D1. Very easy, almost Class 1.
E) Black Rock Pass, Class 1A1. A slog but a long hard strenuous slog.
F) Pterodactyl Pass, Class 2D1. Another very easy one.
G) …and so on.
Look for a future issue of Sierra-Trails featuring the Minarets Cross-Country Traverse. And it may also feature this new rating system.
http://sierrabackpacker.com/sierrapasses-new.htm
I just came back from a trip where my pard and I put together a back-pack mountaineer cross-country (mostly) traverse of the Minarets, going from Fern Lake to 1,000 Island Lake. Once again I was struck by how lame the class ratings are for Class 1 through 3, especially for us who are not normally interested in anything above Class 3. The above link has an excellent explanation of 1-2-3, but I think the rating could go further.
For example, I would do a rating by class, difficulty and exposure. This is needed because, for example, a pass may be easy but very exposed, or very strenuous and somewhat technical but not exposed, and so on. The ratings would be in context of the Class. This is how I would rate things:
1) The Classes would match the explanation in the above link.
2) The Class could be followed by A through D in difficulty, with A being the most difficult/strenuous/technical.
3) The last could be the degree of exposure, 1 through 5, with 5 being the most exposed. A very important consideration.
For example:
A) I just did Nancy Pass, which I would rate as Class 2B1. The pass was not so dangerous (just the usual with loose talus and scree), but it was a pretty strenuous if short in length.
B) Mt. Conness I would rate Class 2D5. Pretty easy to do, but one move puts you over an exposure of about 2000 feet. Don’t slip.
C) Sphinx Pass, Class 2B1. Easy, but you will be very tired when you get there. No exposure.
D) Red Pass, Class 2D1. Very easy, almost Class 1.
E) Black Rock Pass, Class 1A1. A slog but a long hard strenuous slog.
F) Pterodactyl Pass, Class 2D1. Another very easy one.
G) …and so on.
Look for a future issue of Sierra-Trails featuring the Minarets Cross-Country Traverse. And it may also feature this new rating system.