Re: Plan B and B-yond
Posted: Wed Dec 15, 2010 4:06 pm
Sirlight states, "For me when going solo, these must actually be "plans", and not a spur of the moment thing. I consider this rule number one of solo hiking.”
Respectfully, I do not agree. For me the main criteria, “number one” rule for solo hiking is to not to do anything stupid. Regarding plans – set plans – I suppose that if you have someone at home to placate, perhaps leaving a written itinerary, written in blood, has merit. Having a Spot along too then should also be considered, probably even more important than any pre-made plans as with a plan only, the one at home would have to wait until after the due date (might be too late) before any SAR type action would be initiated. Of the two options, carrying the Spot type device would seem to be a more important tool to use today. By leaving daily bread crumbs, one then could still vary the route slightly and still remain in contact and on schedule.
A combination of the two would probably seem to be one’s best insurance for: 1) the fastest possible rescue and, 2) keeping the home front appraised of daily trip progress.
All that being said, I do neither and have done so for years. At one time I made plans scrupulously, followed them to the letter, and missed a lot. Plans made months in advance do not take into account changes presented when actually at the mountain. Weather changes, trailhead quotas get filled, fishing opportunities vary, and new Sierra adventures present themselves daily. If I am at one lake and not getting any action, if another fellow hiker then tells me about better fishing off my intended route, what are my options? Do I stay on route and not catch fish, or do I follow my heart? If the fishing is great, can I stay over a day? How many chances do you have to do what you dreamed about daily for so many months?
Everyone starts out with some plan initially. Solo, you set out boldly and attack the mountain, only to realize (soon enough) that it is the mountain that always sets the pace and always wins no matter how good of shape you are in. After a few days, you accept this fact, take what the Sierra gives, and humbly acquiesce to current conditions…or often kill yourself trying to keep to a pre-set agenda.
I always set out with a plan and a specific trailhead in mind. When I go out with 10 days food and a winter’s plan routed, it is not uncommon though to start north but end up east. I have the maps; I have enough food and enough confidence in my abilities, and 10 days could allow me to go almost anywhere. With rule # 1 (above) always in mind, who knows here my boots will actually lead me?
Just my 2¢
Mark
Respectfully, I do not agree. For me the main criteria, “number one” rule for solo hiking is to not to do anything stupid. Regarding plans – set plans – I suppose that if you have someone at home to placate, perhaps leaving a written itinerary, written in blood, has merit. Having a Spot along too then should also be considered, probably even more important than any pre-made plans as with a plan only, the one at home would have to wait until after the due date (might be too late) before any SAR type action would be initiated. Of the two options, carrying the Spot type device would seem to be a more important tool to use today. By leaving daily bread crumbs, one then could still vary the route slightly and still remain in contact and on schedule.
A combination of the two would probably seem to be one’s best insurance for: 1) the fastest possible rescue and, 2) keeping the home front appraised of daily trip progress.
All that being said, I do neither and have done so for years. At one time I made plans scrupulously, followed them to the letter, and missed a lot. Plans made months in advance do not take into account changes presented when actually at the mountain. Weather changes, trailhead quotas get filled, fishing opportunities vary, and new Sierra adventures present themselves daily. If I am at one lake and not getting any action, if another fellow hiker then tells me about better fishing off my intended route, what are my options? Do I stay on route and not catch fish, or do I follow my heart? If the fishing is great, can I stay over a day? How many chances do you have to do what you dreamed about daily for so many months?
Everyone starts out with some plan initially. Solo, you set out boldly and attack the mountain, only to realize (soon enough) that it is the mountain that always sets the pace and always wins no matter how good of shape you are in. After a few days, you accept this fact, take what the Sierra gives, and humbly acquiesce to current conditions…or often kill yourself trying to keep to a pre-set agenda.
I always set out with a plan and a specific trailhead in mind. When I go out with 10 days food and a winter’s plan routed, it is not uncommon though to start north but end up east. I have the maps; I have enough food and enough confidence in my abilities, and 10 days could allow me to go almost anywhere. With rule # 1 (above) always in mind, who knows here my boots will actually lead me?
Just my 2¢
Mark